Owners have limited time to bring claims against a builder for defective residential work. A recent NCAT Appeal Panel decision shows that owners relying on extra time for late-discovered problems must be able to prove when they found out about each one.

Raysons Constructions Pty Ltd v The Owners – Strata Plan No 87003 [2026] NSWCATAP 324 involved a Meadowbank apartment building completed in 2014. Under the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW), the owners had six years to claim for major defects, until July 2020. They started proceedings in November 2020, claiming cracked slabs, water leaks and drainage problems.

The Act allows for an extra six months when a breach becomes apparent in the last six months of the warranty period. The owner’s corporation said it only learned of the breaches from an expert report in June 2020. The Tribunal agreed and ordered the builder to carry out repairs, even though it found the owners corporation knew of some defects as early as 2014.

In earlier proceedings, the Supreme Court explained that noticing a defect is not the same as knowing the builder has breached its warranty, and that it is up to the owners to prove they qualify for the extension.

The Appeal Panel found the Tribunal had wrongly placed that burden on the builder and had not considered when each breach became apparent. It sent the case back to be heard again by a different Tribunal member and ordered the owners corporation to pay the builder’s appeal costs.

The outcome demonstrates how strictly the time limits for building warranty claims are applied, and the level of evidence owners need before they can rely on the extension.

Leave a Reply