Carrying out development without consent can be costly, even when the land is right next door. A recent Land and Environment Court decision shows how seriously the Court treats unauthorised works on public land.

In Woollahra Municipal Council v Neil Street Co Pty Ltd [2025] NSWLEC 117, a construction company built walls, filled the land and installed stormwater pipes on a council-owned strip of land in Rose Bay that runs down to Sydney Harbour. The land sat beside a home owned by the wife of the company’s director and none of the work had development consent.

The company pleaded guilty to three offences under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW). Charges against the director were dropped after he agreed to pay for repairs costing about $491,000, along with the Council’s costs.Pain J found the stormwater works were the most serious offence. The new pipes were narrower than the Council pipe they connected to, a risk her Honour said would have been obvious to any competent builder.

The company received little credit at sentencing as its guilty pleas came late, earning only a 10% discount, and no director gave evidence of remorse. The Court also refused to treat the director’s agreement as cooperation by the company. As a result, the company was fined $430,000, ordered to pay $75,000 in costs, and required to publish notices of its offences in two newspapers.

The case highlights the significant penalties that can follow unapproved works on public land, and the limited credit available at sentencing where guilty pleas come late.

Leave a Reply