No More Guesswork: NSW Underquoting Reforms Set to Commence on 17 November 2026 and How It Affects Property Owners

For property owners, including investors, the way a property is priced and marketed for sale is about to experience a change. Underquoting has been a longstanding concern within the NSW property market and involves the practice of advertising a property below the price an agent expects it to sell for. From 17 November 2026, amendments made by the Property and Stock Agents Amendment (Underquoting and Other Agent Conduct) Act 2026 (NSW) will significantly tighten the rules for residential sales.

The most prominent change is concerned with how agents arrive at an estimated selling price (ESP). Agents must now consider the sale prices of the three most comparable properties sold within 2 kilometres in the previous 6 months in metropolitan areas, or within 5 kilometres in the previous 18 months in regional areas. The amendments require the agent to give the seller a written estimate of the price or price range, together with the supporting evidence. If the estimate later changes, the seller must be given written notice, and agents must keep records demonstrating how each estimate was derived.

The reforms also affect how a property should be marketed, with every residential sale advertisement being required to include a price or price range. This advertised price cannot be lower than the agent’s estimate, the highest registered bid at a passed-in auction, or a written offer rejected solely on the basis that it was too low. Additionally, if the price changes or an ad becomes non-compliant, online advertisements must be updated or removed within one day.

Penalties for agents also increase significantly, with the maximum penalty being the higher of $110,000 or three times the agent’s commission. NSW Fair Trading can also issue fines of up to $55,000 for corporations.

Moving forward, from 8 February 2027 agents must prepare a Statement of Information for each residential sale which is available to prospective buyers and sets out comparable sales and the ESP.

Ultimately, the reforms represent the most substantial change to NSW price guide regulation in recent years, shifting the basis of advertised prices from agent discretion to documented market evidence.

Building on a Public Road Without Consent Costs Developer $430,000

Carrying out development without consent can be costly, even when the land is right next door. A recent Land and Environment Court decision shows how seriously the Court treats unauthorised works on public land.

In Woollahra Municipal Council v Neil Street Co Pty Ltd [2025] NSWLEC 117, a construction company built walls, filled the land and installed stormwater pipes on a council-owned strip of land in Rose Bay that runs down to Sydney Harbour. The land sat beside a home owned by the wife of the company’s director and none of the work had development consent.

The company pleaded guilty to three offences under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW). Charges against the director were dropped after he agreed to pay for repairs costing about $491,000, along with the Council’s costs.Pain J found the stormwater works were the most serious offence. The new pipes were narrower than the Council pipe they connected to, a risk her Honour said would have been obvious to any competent builder.

The company received little credit at sentencing as its guilty pleas came late, earning only a 10% discount, and no director gave evidence of remorse. The Court also refused to treat the director’s agreement as cooperation by the company. As a result, the company was fined $430,000, ordered to pay $75,000 in costs, and required to publish notices of its offences in two newspapers.

The case highlights the significant penalties that can follow unapproved works on public land, and the limited credit available at sentencing where guilty pleas come late.

Over the Line: Neighbours Ordered to Remove Encroaching Studio

When a building crosses a boundary, the Land and Environment Court can either order it to be removed or order the land beneath it to be transferred to the encroaching owner in exchange for compensation. A recent decision shows how the Court chooses between the two.

In Johnston v Cutbush [2025] NSWLEC 1482, the respondents owned a rural property at Rosebank. In the 1990s, they enlarged an old shed into a studio that extended up to 5.57 metres onto their neighbour’s land. A composting toilet and grey water tank for the studio were later built entirely on the neighbour’s side. None of the work was approved, and the respondents never checked where the boundary was, relying only on what a real estate agent had told them.

The neighbour bought her property in 2016 and planned to use that area for ecotourism. Her main request was for the structures to be removed. The respondents instead asked for 280 square metres of her land to be transferred to them.

Commissioner Gray ordered removal. Apart from the $65,900 removal cost, there was no evidence of hardship to the respondents. The council approvals they later obtained relied on plans wrongly showing the studio within their own land. The land needed for a transfer was also more than three times the land under the structures.

The respondents were given 60 days to remove the studio, toilet and tank at their own expense.

Ultimately, the decision illustrates that the Court will not readily require a neighbour to give up land where an encroachment results from unauthorised building work.

A View Worth Mentioning: Agent’s Half Truth Unwinds $6.2m Bronte Sale

A vendor of Land in NSW is generally under no duty to disclose future possibilities that may affect a property. However, a recent Supreme Court decision confirms that once a vendor or its agent chooses to speal on a subject, a statement that is literally true can still be misleading.

In Keci v Barnes [2026] NSWSC 521, the purchasers exchanged contracts in February 2026 to buy a Bronte home marketed with “sweeping ocean views” for $6.2 million. The adjoining site had consent for nine units, but the Minister had recently declared a proposal for up to 120 dwellings of up to nine storeys on that site to be State Significant Development. The vendors knew of the declaration and had discussed it with their agent.

During inspections, the purchasers asked about the construction next door. The agents told them that nine houses were being built and would not obstruct the ocean views. There was no mention of the larger proposal, which the purchasers later discovered on social media.

Williams J accepted that the statements were literally true. However, because the vendors were promoting the ocean views and the effect of development next door was obvious, a reasonable purchaser would have understood the agents to be conveying everything material known on the subject. By omitting the declaration, the agents impliedly represented that the vendors knew of no facts creating a risk to the views.

It did not matter that the proposal might never proceed, as the risk was real rather than speculative. The Court also rejected the argument that the statements were made in casual conversation, and held that the contract’s “entire agreement” and “no reliance” clauses did not displace their inducing effect. The contract was rescinded and the vendors were ordered to refund the $310,000 deposit.

Ultimately, the decision illustrates the distinction the courts draw between a vendor’s lawful silence and a partial answer that omits known risks.

Mould, Strata Repairs and Lost Rent: The Limits of a Lot Owner’s Claim

Under section 106(5) of the Strata Schemes Management Act 2015 (NSW), a lot owner can recover reasonably foreseeable losses caused by an owners corporation’s (OC) failure to repair common property. A recent NCAT Appeal Panel decision explains how these claims are assessed, and how the Tribunal treats an OC that is late, but willing, to comply with repair orders.

In The Owners – Strata Plan No 6707 v Gaters [2026] NSWCATAP 331, consent orders required the OC of an Auburn scheme to obtain a mould expert’s report and, if recommended, engage a builder to remove mould in a lot and rectify it within four weeks. The report recommended that a builder first assess the sources of water ingress. The OC engaged a contractor to investigate, but access was not sought until after the deadline.

On the lot owner’s renewal application, the Tribunal found the OC had “no intention” of complying and ordered it to pay $10,635. The owner’s claims for medical expenses and $39,514 in lost rent were dismissed.

The Appeal Panel allowed the OC’s appeal. Investigating the water ingress was exactly what the expert had recommended and fell within the original order, and the finding that the OC had no intention of complying was against the weight of the evidence. As the Tribunal’s discretion had been exercised on a mistaken view of the facts, the matter was remitted for rehearing.

The owner’s cross-appeal was dismissed. He had continued to live in the unit, so the “potential” to earn rent was not an actual loss. The Panel added that a lost rent claim must be supported by sworn evidence and assessed on net income after expenses. The medical expenses claim failed for want of evidence linking the owner’s condition to a breach by the OC.

Ultimately, the decision illustrates that section 106(5) compensates for actual, proven loss, and that an OC’s efforts to comply are relevant to the Tribunal’s discretion on renewal.

Make Good Clauses: When Does a Tenant Have to Remove Its Fit-Out?

Make good disputes often arise when a long commercial lease ends. A recent NSW Supreme Court decision shows that their resolution depends on reading the lease as a whole, rather than interpreting a single phrase in isolation.

Allied Pinnacle Pty Ltd v G R Mailman & Associates Pty Ltd [2026] NSWSC 87 concerned commercial premises at Huntingwood in Western Sydney. The tenant took a ten-year lease in 2015, with options for two further five-year terms, and installed a substantial fit-out at the start of its tenancy. The current landlord bought the premises in late 2017. The tenant did not exercise its option and vacated in August 2025, leaving the fit-out in place.

The central question was the meaning of clause A2.1, which required the tenant to yield up the premises consistent with their “condition” at the commencement of the lease. The landlord argued this meant restoring the pre-fit-out layout. Muston J preferred the tenant’s view that “condition” referred to the standard of the premises, not their configuration. The word was used in that sense in clauses A2.2(c) and A24.5, and the more specific make good provisions in clause A24, which prevailed, contained no reinstatement obligation. Clause B1(22) also gave the tenant a discretionary right to remove its fixtures, which would have been pointless if removal was compulsory.

The tenant did not escape liability entirely. Clause A24.3(b) required repainting of “all painted surfaces”, including the exterior, and the tenant was liable for outstanding redecoration works, including furniture removal, internal repainting and carpet works. The Court rejected arguments based on failure to mitigate, repudiation, waiver, estoppel and an implied duty of good faith, and found that the unconscionable conduct claim would have failed in any event. Damages were referred to by the referee.

Ultimately, the decision illustrates that general yield-up wording will be read in light of the lease’s more specific make good provisions.

Family Development Dispute Ends in Court-Ordered Sale Under Section 66G of the Conveyancing Act

Informal arrangements between relatives to buy and develop property together can be difficult to unwind if the relationship breaks down. A recent NSW Supreme Court decision illustrates how readily the Court will order the sale of co-owned land.

In Russo v Russo [2026] NSWSC 4, an uncle and nephew, both licensed builders, bought land at Revesby in 2015 for $950,000 as tenants in common in equal shares. They agreed orally to subdivide it and build two detached houses, each with a pool, using the nephew’s construction company, with each taking one house. The subdivision was registered in 2022, but the planned partition never occurred. After disputes over development costs, the uncle applied under section 66G of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW) for trustees to be appointed to sell the properties.

Richmond J confirmed that a co-owner is entitled to a section 66G order almost as of right, with the onus on the co-owner opposing it. An order may be refused where a sale would be inconsistent with a contractual right, but not merely for hardship or unfairness.

The nephew relied on the agreed term that each would become the registered proprietor of one lot. However, the Court found the parties had agreed the houses would be the same, a term given effect by a building contract requiring variations to be agreed in writing. Without such a variation, the nephew built his house using a more expensive concrete panelling system, so the term was not enlivened and did not prevent a sale.

Trustees could not be appointed immediately, as section 66G requires at least two individual trustees and only one had been proposed. Two trustees were later appointed in Russo v Russo (No 2) [2026] NSWSC 311. The nephew’s cross-claim for $335,392.12 in unpaid contributions was dismissed, as his records were uncorroborated and many entries were unrelated to the development.

Ultimately, the decision illustrates the limited weight an informal arrangement between co-owners may carry once the relationship has broken down.